In October, 1969, just a month before the previous case, two sisters of Edgewater, another town in the Trench, Mrs. Lorraine Goodwin and Mrs. Janice Schneider, had the terrifying experience of having a UFO repeatedly dive at them while they were driving with their five children in the car.

The object, a brilliant light alternating between red and green, took up the attack soon after they had left Cranbrook, close to the international border, in the late afternoon to proceed north toward home. Zooming in from one side, the light almost landed on the car and stayed there momentarily before darting off to the side again. This performance was repeated several times over a distance of about 15 miles. The group became so alarmed they nearly went in the ditch.